ss

Home invasion case heads to grand jury

ELYRIA — An Elyria man accused of murder in a botched robbery last month that left two dead and a third man wounded agreed Friday to have his case bound over to a county grand jury.

Brady Phillips, 38, also faces felonious assault and aggravated robbery charges for allegedly forcing his way into a David Drive apartment shared by David McDonough and Michael Stump on Dec. 20.

Police say Stump was shot in the head by Herminio Serrano — whom police say was Phillips’ partner in the robbery — and died the next day. McDonough, who was shot in the abdomen, shot and killed Serrano, according to police.

Phillips fled the scene and was arrested the next day.

McDonough has since been released from the hospital, according to Elyria City Prosecutor Jay Grunda.

During Friday’s hearing, Grunda said Phillips and Serrano targeted one of two safes that were in the apartment.

The plan, Grunda said, was they were “going to get some money from ‘the white guys.’ ” Both McDonough and Stump are white, while Phillips is black and Serrano was Hispanic.

The mother of one of Stump’s children has said Stump was trying to clean up his life, but was still dealing prescription drugs to make ends meet while he looked for work.

Doug Merrill, Phillips’ defense attorney, said his client was at the scene, but didn’t fire a gun.

“He’s maintaining his innocence, and I think what the evidence is going to show is he did not possess a weapon and he didn’t fire a weapon,” Merrill said.

Grunda said Phillips had given a .38-caliber revolver to Serrano to use during the robbery. A 9 mm semiautomatic pistol also was found in the apartment.

Merrill asked Elyria Municipal Court Judge Lisa Locke Graves to reduce Phillips’ bond, which is set at $1 million on both the felonious assault and aggravated robbery charges. He also asked for a bond to be set on the murder charge, which Locke Graves had ordered Phillips held on without bond at a hearing last year.

Grunda argued against reduced bonds in part because of Phillips’ extensive record of violence, illegal possession of weapons and burglary. He also said that if Phillips was released, it could put witnesses in the case in danger.

“There were a couple other people (at the apartment) as well who could be in danger,” Grunda said after the hearing.

Locke Graves left the bonds she imposed last month in place, which means he will remain in the county jail.

Police and friends of Stump have said there were other people at the apartment the night of the shootings for a small party, but Grunda said investigators are still trying to piece together exactly what happened.

At least one woman banged on the doors of apartments in which foreign exchange students attending Lorain County Community College live the night of the shooting, seeking refuge after the robbery.

Contact Brad Dicken at 329-7147 or bdicken@chroniclet.com.



Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.